Illinois’ Best Pizza Slice Is a Late-Night Anthem in Chicago

Chicago has no shortage of pizza spots, from towering deep-dish pies to foldable slices you can eat while sprinting for the “L.” But tucked away in River West is one joint that doesn’t just serve pizza; it serves an experience.

A Pizza That Rocks as Hard as the Bands

With walls plastered in band flyers and a menu inspired by heavy metal riffs, this is the kind of place that feels more like a backstage pass than a late-night restaurant.

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria

What Makes Pie-Eyed Different

Sure, you’ll find the usual thin-crust and deep-dish choices here, but Pie-Eyed cranks it up to 11 with slices that pay tribute to legendary rock bands. Ever heard of the Black Sabbath Pizza or the Red Hot Chili Pie (below)?

They’ve both made local TV appearances. And one of their best-sellers? A supreme-style monster slice inspired by Gwar — loaded with hot soppressata, applewood-smoked bacon, Italian sausage, pepperoni, red bell peppers, and extra sauce.

MORE: Illinois Pizzerias With The Highest Scores From Dave Portnoy's One Bite Reviews

Why It’s the Ultimate Late-Night Bite

Here’s the kicker: Pie-Eyed serves slices until 5 a.m. on weekends. That means after a night at Riot Fest, a Cubs game, or even just a questionable karaoke set, this is the place to refuel. For Rockford folks making the trek into Chicago, think of it as the reward at the end of your night out.

A recent Food Network survey named this one of the 50 Best Slices of Pizza in the US.

MORE: Chefs Agree, Illinois Pizza Joint Serves Best Slice in America

Worth the Drive From Anywhere in Illinois

If your idea of a perfect slice is equal parts bold flavor and late-night energy, Pie-Eyed Pizzeria isn’t just Illinois’ best; it appears to be a rite of passage. Located at 1111 W Chicago Ave, Chicago. Visit pie-eyedpizzeria.com.

MORE: Chicago Rooftop Movie Nights Return With Popcorn, Cocktails, and Iconic Films