Should Illinois or Northwestern be considered ‘our college?’
Which Big 10 school should be considered “our school?”
On Thursday at 3:30 p.m., Northwestern will play its first NCAA tournament game in history when the Wildcats take on Vanderbilt.
This has been a big story nationally, but it doesn’t seem to be as big in Rockford. My guess is that if you took a poll, more sports fans locally follow Illinois rather than Northwestern. Even Wisconsin might have a bigger fan base here.
If you look at which of those Big 10 schools pay attention to Rockford, well Northwestern should be considered our team. I don’t have a list of every single athlete from our area that made a splash at Illinois and Northwestern, but my list is better than anyone else’s.
Here’s a list of locals who made an impact at Northwestern in the major sports since 1950:
Football – Bobby Anderson (Auburn), Mitch Anderson (East), Todd Jenkins (Freeport), Dean Lowry (Boylan), Zeke Markhausen (North Boone), Ray Robey (Auburn), Tim Scharf (Boylan), Lenny Williams (Guilford)
Men’s basketball – Bill Cacciatore (West), Andre Goode (East), Mark Sibley (West), Greg Wells (West)
Women’s basketball – Stacy Neal (South Beloit)
Baseball – Dick Noffke (Boylan)
Here’s the competing list of local players who excelled at Illinois since 1950:
Football – Marshall Starks (West), Shawn Wax (Harlem), David Olson (Freeport), Bucky Babcok (Stillman Valley), LeRon Hill (Rochelle)
Men’s basketball – Tom Carmichael (Rochelle), Damir Krupalija (Boylan), Preston Pearson (Freeport), Perry Range (South Beloit), Skip Thoren (East), John Wessels (West).
Women’s basketball – Aminata Yanni (Harlem)
Baseball – Drew Dickinson (Freeport), Matt Vorwald (Freeport)
To be fair, the biggest recruit from the NIC-10 this year was Auburn’s Vederian Lowe, who signed with Illinois.
Just for comparison, here are our impact Badgers since 1950:
Football – Ron Carlson (East), Troy King (Freeport), Ira Matthews (East), Jerry Stalcup (East), Steve Stark (Hononegah).
Men’s basketball: Pete Anderson (East), Fred Clow (East), Kerry Hughes (Freeport), Kim Hughes (Freeport), Danny Jones (Boylan), Ab Nicholas (West)
Women’s basketball – none
Baseball – Rod Myers (East) * Wisconsin no longer has baseball
So while Illinois searches for a replacement for John Groce, we can cheer on Northwestern, the school that looks our way most often.